Pyrgus key - upperside view
This is attempt at an identification key for Pyrgus species based on the upperside view.
There are generally less unique distinguishing features on the upperside than the underside
but, taken in combination, should increase the chances of positive identification to near 100%.
A key based on the underside view is here.
note: location, flight period, altitude have not been included in the criteria.
note: the descriptions below only apply to the male of each species. Females are generally similar but more weakly marked.
note: these observations will hold true for about 90% of specimens, but natural variation will produce some that do not fit the "classical" template.
for instance, the P. serratulae forewing is normally lightly marked, but in some regions specimens have marks significantly stronger than the norm.
note: a number of species have geographical variation and/or subspecies such as P. alveus accretus and P. bellieri picenus;
further data needs to be collected before these can be included in an analysis of this type.
The two main upperside marks are circled above. For other marks, the wing diagram is here.
The terms "spot" and "mark" are used interchangeably as terms such as "cell spot" are in common usage.
The terms strong/medium/weak are used to describe the strength of the marks. These are relative terms, although strong means that the mark is
clear and well contrasted against the background colour.
upf = upperside forewing: uph = upperside hindwing
Start here:
It is suggested that each step is taken in the order shown, to eliminate those species with a unique defining characteristic.
Size (small/medium/large) is given as an additional indicator, although size is relative and can vary; as a baseline, P. malvae (or malvoides) is small.
step | characteristic | size | yes | no |
1 | uph discal spot strong, rectangular, white and deeply cleft at the base in the form of a letter "K"; alternatively, simply a white horizontal line at the top of the discal spot | small | 2 | 3 |
2 | upf mark strong and white, uph sub-marginal marks (wing diagram) complete, strong and often sagittate. Note: the uph sub-marginal marks of malvoides are usually more diffuse that those of malvae | small | malvae/malvoides | 30 |
3 | upf marks strong and white and having noticeably jagged edges | large | 4 | 5 |
4 | uph marks strong and white | large | bellieri (foulquieri) | 30 |
5 | upf cell spot wide and rectangular | medium | 6 | 8 |
6 | upf post-discal marks in s1/s2 joined and offset slightly suggesting the shape of a waving flag | medium | 7 | 8 |
7 | uph discal spot strong and off-white or pale yellow | medium | cirsii | 30 |
8 | upf cell spot in the form of an externally-facing "C"; this may be a "(" shape or even a "<" shape, or somewhere in-between, and the mark may be of varying thickness | medium | 9 | 10 |
9 | uph marks of medium strength | medium | carlinae | 30 |
10 | upf marks white and complete and of medium strength | medium | 11 | 12 |
11 | uph discal spot white to off-white, rectangular and often thinly vertically divided in the middle (marks more pronounced in summer brood) | medium | armoricanus | 30 |
12 | upf white marks generally complete and quite strong, including the cell spot | medium | 13 | 14 |
13 | uph marks of medium strength | medium | onopordi | 12 |
14 | uph sub-marginal marks (wing diagram) elongated, upf marks complete and strong | large | 15 | 17 |
15 | uph sub-marginal marks (wing diagram) particularly thin and straight | large | carthami | 16 |
16 | uph sub-marginal marks (wing diagram) complete and strong but not thin. | large | sidae | 30 |
17 | uph marks absent or very weak | 18 | 30 | |
18 | uph marks completely absent | 19 | 23 | |
19 | three small white marks in the upf discal region (two in s1 one in s2) broadly in line | medium | andromedae | 20 |
20 | upf white marks very small, forewing narrow | small | warrenensis | 21 |
21 | upf white marks very small, separated, and usually more squarish than rectangular | medium/large | cacaliae | 22 |
22 | upf white marks small-ish and cell spot weak | medium | serratulae | 30 |
23 | upf white marks of medium size, cell spot rather weak or absent | large/medium | alveus | 30 |
30 | This one doesn't seem to fit the "classical" template. |